Chemistry Ages 14–16

Mendeleev's gamble

He left gaps in his table and bet that nature would fill them.

He left gaps in his table and predicted elements no one had seen. Students rebuild his method and score his bets in a 32-slide lesson for ages 14–16.

The short answer

Mendeleev arranged elements in rows by atomic weight and in columns by family, and left gaps where no known element fitted. From the neighbours he predicted the missing elements. In 1871 he gave eka-silicon a mass of 72 and density 5.5; germanium, found in 1886, had 72.6 and 5.3, less than 1% out on mass.

Inside the deck

slides
32
quiz questions
8
minutes
70
your-turn tasks
6

Choose a format

  • Lesson Notes (PDF)Every slide with its teacher notes, as a PDF to read or print.
  • Teacher DeckThe editable PowerPoint with speaker notes on every slide, a PDF copy and the matching Vesper slide template, so you can add slides of your own.
Pricing coming soon

Pricing coming soon

We’ll email you pricing and launch offers shortly.

  • Finished and checked: buying opens soon
  • Sources listed at the end
  • Curriculum links under ‘Curriculum & specs’
  • For one classroom. Campus licences for whole schools

Key facts

  • Before 1869 about 63 elements were known
  • Mendeleev predicted eka-silicon at mass 72; germanium (1886) is 72.6, about 0.8% out
  • Three gaps, three hits: gallium 1875, scandium 1879, germanium 1886
  • Moseley's atomic numbers (1913) put tellurium (52) before iodine (53)
  • Triad check: (35.5 + 127) ÷ 2 = 81.25 against bromine's real 79.9

What students will be able to do

  • Students can explain how Mendeleev ordered the elements and why he left gaps
  • Students can predict a missing element's mass from its neighbours
  • Students can predict formulas from a column and balance the equations
  • Students can calculate the percentage error of a prediction
  • Students can explain why atomic number, not mass, gives the true order

About this lesson

What students discover

In 1871 Dmitri Mendeleev described an element nobody had found: atomic mass 72, density 5.5. In 1886 germanium turned up with 72.6 and 5.3. Students work through the clues he had (Döbereiner’s triads, Newlands’ octaves), see how he sorted elements like cards by weight and family, and why he left gaps and named them in Sanskrit: eka-boron, eka-aluminium, eka-silicon.

Then they predict like he did: masses from neighbours, formulas from columns, with balanced equations for GeCl4 and Ga2O3, and they score his predictions with a percentage error. The story goes on to the gallium density he corrected, the tellurium-iodine swap that Moseley’s atomic numbers proved right in 1913, the noble gases, and a prediction that failed.

Inside the deck

32 slides on the Flask template with worked examples, two your-turn predictions, a spot-the-mistake on tellurium and iodine, a quick poll on what makes a good prediction, two checkpoints and an 8-question quiz with explained answers. A paper card game (elements 1–20, a partner hides three cards) lets learners play his game.

How to teach it

Plan on about 70 minutes. Open with the 1871 prediction and the three-option guess, then reveal germanium’s real values. The card game on slide 24 works in pairs in 10 minutes. The ‘dream’ story is labelled as legend, so you can discuss how science stories grow. Notes on every slide give Say, Ask, Watch for and Time.

Who it’s for

For ages 14–16 studying the periodic table, atomic number and the nature of science. It also suits a history-of-science lesson. The PowerPoint is editable, with named layouts for your own slides.

Curriculum & specs

CBSE/NCERT (India)Class 9-10 · Not in current CBSE book (Periodic Classification removed from Class 10 in 2023). Link: Class 9 Exploration ch 9 Atomic Foundations of Matter
CambridgeLS Stage 9 Chemistry (Periodic Table); IGCSE 0620 §8 The Periodic Table
NGSS (US)HS-PS1-1
IB MYPSciences · KC Relationships · RC Patterns, Evidence · Crit D
Ages14–16
LevelSenior
Slide templateFlask
Slides32
Teaching timeAbout 70 minutes
LanguageEnglish (UK)

Questions

Questions, answered

How did Mendeleev predict new elements?

He arranged known elements by atomic weight in rows and by similar properties in columns. Where nothing fitted he left a gap, then predicted the missing element's mass, density and formulas from its neighbours.

Which elements did Mendeleev predict?

Eka-aluminium, eka-boron and eka-silicon, found as gallium (1875), scandium (1879) and germanium (1886).

Why did Mendeleev put tellurium before iodine?

Iodine behaves like the halogens, so he placed it by its properties even though tellurium is slightly heavier. Moseley's atomic numbers in 1913 showed he was right: Te is 52 and I is 53.

What does eka mean in eka-silicon?

Eka is Sanskrit for 'one'. Eka-silicon meant the element one place below silicon in the table.

Did all of Mendeleev's predictions come true?

No. In 1902 he proposed elements lighter than hydrogen, which do not exist. The lesson uses this to show that good predictions are specific enough to fail.

What age is this periodic table lesson for?

Ages 14–16. It takes about 70 minutes and includes a card game, two checkpoints and an 8-question quiz.

Main sources

  1. Chemeurope encyclopedia, "Mendeleev's predicted elements" (predicted vs observed values; scandium 1879, Nilson).
  2. E. Scerri, The Periodic Table: Its Story and Its Significance (OUP, 2007): gallium density story, eka- names.
  3. RSC Periodic Table: germanium, Winkler 1886, 5.32 g/cm³. Masses: IUPAC, rounded.

The full source list is on the last slides of the deck. Spotted an error? Tell us.