About this lesson
What students discover
Is Pluto a planet? Students start by voting, then act as the jury. They weigh real evidence. Pluto, found by Clyde Tombaugh on 18 February 1930, is 2,377 km wide, about two-thirds the width of our Moon, with just 0.2% of Earth’s mass: about 460 Plutos would match one Earth. Its orbit is tilted 17° and crosses Neptune’s, and it shares the Kuiper Belt with more than a thousand icy objects found since 1992.
Then came Eris, announced in 2005 and 27% heavier than Pluto, which forced astronomers to define the word ‘planet’ for the first time. Students follow the vote in Prague on 24 August 2006 (237 for, 157 against), learn the IAU’s three tests, and see ‘clearing the neighbourhood’ as a simple mass ratio: Earth outweighs everything else in its lane about 1.7 million to 1, while Pluto scores 0.077. A myth slide fixes ‘Pluto lost because it’s too small’. New Horizons’ 2015 flyby, with a heart whose left half is a slowly flowing plain of nitrogen ice, shows Pluto is a fascinating world whatever we call it.
Inside the deck
32 slides on the Nova template: a voting hook, a primer, a people slide, two diagram walks, three evidence slides, five your-turn tasks, two checkpoints and a judging activity on four worlds (Jupiter, Ceres, Eris and the Moon). A frontier slide lays out two expert opinions, clearly labelled as opinions. A seven-question quiz has explained answers.
How to teach it
About 65 minutes. Keep the slide 3 votes and compare them on slide 25. The closing task asks students to argue either side in three sentences (claim, evidence, reasoning), which makes this a strong lesson for teaching scientific argument as well as astronomy.
Who it’s for
Learners aged 11–13, and any class that enjoys a good argument settled by evidence.








